002
The amount of matter in the universe is finite and constant. Every system is circular because everything we do is a rearrangement of one state into another. The world forms itself between order and entropy as a circular system.
Talk · Mesh Festival 2026 · Basel · 17 October 2026
Over the past decades computational systems have suggested care and produced chaos. This talk proposes information design as a way of observing the interfaces, computations and data structures we live inside, and of turning that observation into a way of thinking through designed structures. Following the idea of ontological design, designing is never only the making of things. It is the making of what we are. Kim Albrecht closes by asking what it means to design not only for what our systems make present, but also for what they displace, neglect or leave unseen.
01
The amount of matter in the universe is finite and constant. Every system is circular because everything we do is a rearrangement of one state into another. The world forms itself between order and entropy as a circular system.
Today I want to talk about one specific circular system. A circle so grandiose, so vast that it is difficult to grasp, see, or understand. At the same time it is so simple that it is easy to overlook.
The circle I want to discuss is the one between being human and design.
In one way or another, our entire experience of reality is designed. This includes the toothpaste we use every day, our kitchen supplies, our means of communication, our clothing and fashion, our creative processes, our factories and infrastructure, our transport systems and energy grids, our cities and supply chains, and the computational megastructure of information technology.
“We literally live inside design, like the spider lives inside the web constructed from inside its own body.”
Or as Anne-Marie Willis framed it: “We design our world, while our world acts back on us and designs us.”
What defines us as human beings is not inside our bodies or brains, but rather within the artifacts, systems, and structures we create.
This notion is known as ontological design: What makes us human are the structures and systems we embed ourselves in.
02
For the past decade and a half, I have been working to make data visible, understandable, and tangible by visualizing it. My work ranges from creating scientific images and conducting investigative research to staging theater performances, creating installations, and designing exhibitions.
Visualization design follows a simple pattern:
Over the past decade, I have researched ways to break with this pattern by using visualizations to point not primarily toward the world, but toward the systems, settings, and infrastructures that make data, information, and computation possible.
I visualize the meta perspectives of interfaces.
This is a change in perspective, not a change in tools or methods. Through this, my questions, interests, and motives are shifting.
The digital world is shaped by the social constructs that define our perception of reality. For me, information design is a way to explore the ontological spaces in which we situate ourselves.
I do not consider the relationship between humans and design to be a single system.
Rather, I see it as a vast, complex network of interacting, overlapping, and alternating loops.
Mapping, diagramming, and visualization are capable of tracing the structures we are embedded in within the architecture of designed systems.
These maps are not monolithic; they offer different perspectives and are subjective representations of the loop. Maps enable us to examine systems from specific viewpoints.
Visualization can act as a second order observation, a meta perspective on the systems and circles we are embedded in.
These mappings do not only allow us to investigate the feedback between humans and design, but also what has been neglected. Visualization can look not only at the structures, but also at the shadows they leave behind.
Today, it’s not only humans who design. Machines have started designing, too. The circle duplicates and shifts in these new transitions. Visualization can investigate the loops, shadows, and strange overlaps that happen in-between.
01
I want to showcase a book project I am currently finalizing and that will be published next spring. Segments explores one malfunctioning of a circular system in the relationship between humans and design. It is a book project, an atlas and an investigation.
On June 9th 2022 a blog post appeared on the company website of the digital advertising company Xandr called “Data Marketplace – Buyer Overview”. Only days before Microsoft acquired Xandr for roughly 1 Billion dollars.
Xandr was an online platform for buying and selling consumer-centric digital advertising. A marketplace for data brokers. One year after the acquisition Microsoft dissolved the brand into other products.
Data brokers buy, scrape, and collect data from a variety of sources.
They clean and connect these data sources to create profiles and segments.
Then, they sell these segments for advertising, finance, employment checks, research, government, and law enforcement.
Data brokers are a multi-billion dollar industry.
Acxiom managed 3.7 billion consumer profiles. That is almost half of all humans on earth. Oracle aggregated three billion user profiles and is analyzing 700 million social media messages, blogs, and consumer reviews daily for clustering and segmentation.
Data brokers’ operations are so powerful that NATO published a report saying that they are among the most powerful organizations in today’s digital world.
At the same time data brokers operate in the dark. In “The Age of Surveillance Capitalism” (2019), one of the most influential accounts of digital capitalism, Shoshana Zuboff mentions data brokers only once in over 500 pages. We are all tracked, segmented and targeted with almost no discussion.
The combination of power, reach, opacity, and neglect turns data brokers into one of the least scrutinized yet most consequential forces in the contemporary information economy.
The data broker industry is a giant circular system between your online behavior, your devices, a practice called data harvesting, the content we see, the needs, wants, and desires that drive our daily lived reality and a surveillance complex spanning corporations and governmental agencies.
This brings me back to this blogpost. Within the blogpost someone at the company published an Excel spreadsheet with over 650,000 segments.
Data brokerage segments suddenly became public. What is usually hidden behind interface operations became visible. While a few journalists reported on it, the content of the dataset is largely unexplored.
We are all classified across thousands of behavioral, emotional, and moral dimensions: as pro-life or pro-choice supporters, as people with alcohol dependence or eating disorders, as daily horoscope readers, bankrupt individuals, users of life-support devices, or condom users. The degree of intrusion into personal and private life is unfathomable.
Here is an overview of all the 93 data brokers contained in the dataset.
02
The main idea of the book is to depict and expose the ontology of commercial classification.
I started mapping and categorizing the structure of the dataset and its actors.
A large part of the dataset consists of infrastructural terminologies.
Market Behavior and consumer behavior are the largest distinctive categories we are sorted into.
That said, the dataset goes far beyond these realms, touching our political affiliations, lifestyle and interests, health and medical conditions, as well as our geographic settings and movements.
The data broker industry is located in the United States and in Europe, but its operations are global, acting from the global north onto the global south.
The dataset clearly shows a power dynamic that repeats itself in technological infrastructures and beyond.
There is no correlation between the number of employees, the number of segments per provider, and the revenue these companies make. Brokerage is a strange reality, hidden and hard to grasp even through a dataset like this.
The book is becoming an atlas of data brokers. Visualizing the hierarchical trees we are all categorized by while using our digital devices.
Not everything about this dataset is evil, nor is it systematic. The data is messy and strange, but always with a clear intent: to make money.
The book is structured in three parts. The first part describes the theoretical settings of the industry, the dataset and its meaning within the system, the second investigates all providers within the dataset from small-scale start-ups to globally acting corporations, and the third searches for illegal and problematic terms displaying the fragmentation in which these companies exploit humanity.
Here you see one spread of segmentations on search terms around gambling.
By the late sixteenth century the term segment was used in geometry to describe a portion of a circle separated from the whole. What began as a spatial operation, cutting a continuous form into discrete units, gradually became a general principle of organization. The cut persists, but its object has shifted, from circles to populations.
The leak is now four years old. It was published at a pivotal moment, five months before the release of ChatGPT to the public. The founding dates of these companies go back 100 years, but most of them are from this century. Currently the industry is in a major transition due to the vast changes in machine learning. But make no mistake, this dataset is far from irrelevant. It is haunting us from the past into the future.
In 2025 Larry Ellison, the CTO of Oracle, one of the largest providers in the dataset, said this:
“So if you look at ChatGPT or Anthropic, Grok, Llama, what have you. They’re all trained on all of the data on the internet. In other words, publicly available data. But for these models to reach their peak value, you need to not just train them on publicly available data, but you need to make private, privately owned data available to those models as well.”
I am concerned that Ellison is discussing the segments I am researching, as well as their extensive connections to us. These companies probably train machines to understand our needs, wants, and desires. This is a circular system we are all embedded in, but one that is not favorable.
The loop between design, human and machine is strangely warped. It is not linear, it is temporal.
Data from the past reappears in new form through design. AI and big data are not different things but the same ghost reappearing under new names.
In the beginning of this talk I introduced the notion of Ontological Design, that what makes us human is dependent on the structures and systems we embed ourselves in. But maybe the term Ontological Design does not fully grasp the situation.
In 1993 Jacques Derrida coined the term hauntology. Reality is never simply the present moment. It is always full of traces, ghosts, and history. I am wondering whether we should speak of Hauntological Design instead.
In Discriminating Data Wendy Chun argues that machine learning predicts the future by training on the past, so the future repeats the past.
The question is: What are the ghosts from the past that are haunting us into the future?
Do they ever return to possess the living? Yes, they do.
Design, unlike the laws of physics, can always be different. It is something that we set as individuals, a collective, as a society, a nation state, and a global community. Everything we design can be different.
Computation facilitates control. But because design can differ, there is also opportunity for care.